Literary friend or foe?

In recent years, reading has attained ‘cool girl’ status. BookTok and Bookstagram (Book TikTok and Book Instagram, respectively) have gained a significant foothold in the social media sphere. Bookshops have dedicated ‘BookTok’ shelves, and publishing presses are launching new imprints based on current trending hashtags. Those with a significant foothold in the book world are now dedicating sections of their business plan to these internet communities and their influence. 

While reading has historically been considered a feminine pastime, the realm of fantasy has been overwhelmingly dominated by men in both readership and authorship. Series like Lord of the Rings and The Chronicles of Narnia are considered foundational texts of the genre (with good reason). When looking for recommendations, you are likely to hear names such as Brandon Sanderson, Terry Pratchett and Isaac Asimov. You may have heard of literary powerhouses such as Ursula K. Le Guin and Margaret Atwood, but an overwhelming majority of popular fantasy writers are men. It is not surprising that only 15 of the books on NPR’s Top 100 Science-Fiction and Fantasy survey were written by women, and only one made the top 20 (Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein).


The advent of romantasy has changed this. Whether you’re a longtime reader or you’ve recently discovered a love for books, you have likely heard of the series A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR). Written by Sarah J. Maas, this series is considered by many as the poster child for a genre dubbed by readers as ‘romantasy’, or romantic fantasy. Maas’ works have dominated online conversations in recent years, gaining huge popularity on BookTok and Bookstagram. 


Along with Rebecca Yarros (Fourth Wing), Maas is one of the most successful contemporary authors in the current market, and is considered to be one of the go-to romantasy authors. Her most recent publication, A Court of Splintered Harmony, drew crowds somewhat reminiscent of the Harry Potter release days. Thousands of fans lined city streets and filled shopping centres in the hours leading up to midnight, eagerly awaiting the opportunity to purchase the newest iteration in the ACOTAR series. The sales figures on release day, October 27th 2026, reached 1.7 million copies, breaking Maas’ previous record and displaying the significant audience she has amassed since her debut in 2012.

While the term ‘romantasy’ might be a new phenomenon, the subgenre itself has been around for years. Some members of online book communities cite Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments and its numerous companion series as the origin of the genre. Beginning with City of Bones, the series sold millions of copies worldwide and gained a devout, majority female readership. Other contenders include the Vampire Academy series and, of course, Stephanie Meyers’ Twilight series.


If the genre has been around since at least the 90s and 2000s, why has this explosion in popularity come in the 2020s? Well, Maas and her counterparts have introduced an aspect to their novels that sets them apart from many of the popular early examples of the genre: smut. A controversial addition, this element to these novels has drawn criticism and even contempt from many in the literary sphere. Some assign Maas’ works the title of ‘fairy porn,’ something deserving derision, while others have stated that her books ‘don’t count’ as reading.


Some argue that the romantasy label diminishes a book, and that it is a uniquely feminine genre. While many popular male fantasy authors have written novels that include romance as a key part of the plot, their books are simply considered fantasy. For example, Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn trilogy has a significant romantic subplot and a female protagonist, but escapes the romantasy label. An argument could be made that most popular books in the genre include the aforementioned smut element (or ‘spice’, as BookTok has dubbed it), yet George R.R. Martin’s R-rated scenes in A Game of Thrones do not suffice to categorise the book as romantasy. 


Discourse aside, romantasy novels have been the primary driver of the huge increase in the popularity of the sci-fi/fantasy genre. The value of the genre in the UK market increased by 41.3% between 2023 and 2024, and its readership has expanded significantly. People who hadn’t so much as touched a book since school are now reading multiple books a month, and publishers are investing more time and money into fantasy. Many readers online have also shared how, after picking up a romantasy book, they discovered a love for reading, which subsequently led them to read many other genres, showing how the popularity of romantasy can benefit books across the board.


Independent bookshops have also benefited from the romantasy craze. Many held launch parties and offered exclusive deals on recent popular publications, which drove massive increases in sales for these small businesses. Indie bookshops have struggled for years to compete with the likes of Amazon and big chain stores, so these events are hugely beneficial to them. Many romantasy fans have also formed literary communities, from book clubs to costume parties, which have brought women together to bond over their shared love for these books.

Considering the current literary crisis, the rise of AI, and the shaky foundations of the book industry as a whole, anything that promotes reading should be celebrated. While you may not enjoy the subject matter, the writing style, or even the genre as a whole, more people reading is a good thing. A gateway into the literary world should be welcomed.


Written By: Kate O’Connor Shivnan

Edited By: Freddie Kagino

Previous
Previous

Poetry isn't dead, the girls just brought it to the pub

Next
Next

The Brand Reshaping Scottish Fashion:An Interview with Jordan Fergusson.